Not Taylor Made

2 04 2008

Letters of intent are tricky. In Tyshawn Taylor’s case, that may be an understatement. With our beloved Tom Crean going to Indiana, Taylor is asking Marquette to nullify his letter of intent to play basketball for them.


It’s no surprise that high school kids go to a school to play for the coach. The basketball player goes where he will fit into the style and where he’s built up a rapport with the coaching staff. With the exception of UCLA, Kentucky and a select few other schools, kids don’t play for programs. The question then becomes how are poached collegiate coaches held accountable? What exactly do we expect from ballers and why? I’ve asked this question before in a different context.

The Taylor camp is not outwardly malignant towards Crean. Even though Crean dumped Marquette in a move faster than Shaq dumps franchises, Taylor seems to think that there is a possibility that he will follow Crean to God’s Country.

And now Taylor’s high school coach, Bob Hurley, says that the coach Marquette installs will have to be someone he knows really well. Okay… like that makes sense. I doubt Mrs. Hurley or anyone from Hurley’s ol’ gang will travel to the midwest and accept a vacant coaching position in Milwaukee, Wisconsin.

Hurley doesn’t want anything to do with the school which is ironic because he’s projecting his frustration with Crean onto the school. Anyone else find it odd that a recruit would shun a school that got burned before the college coach that broke his commitment to his players?

College coaches leave for greener pastures every season. They are hardly ever held accountable for the kids they have left. Coaches can’t say “come with me” because it’s against NCAA regulations. The young athletes are left to their own devices. They are at the mercy of a new coach. They have no emotional armor save for comforting words from their equally confused and shell-shocked teammates.

The question then becomes whether or not Marquette releases their players from letters of intent. If it does not, you will find disgruntled players bringing down team chemistry and then dashing for the door like they got a blind date with Fran Drescher. It can also hurt the program’s reputation with influential high school coaches and prospective players.

All is lost anyway so if the school tears up the letters of intent, it may be the smart play. Unless Marquette gets a big-name coach immediately, it’s time to rebuild. Their cause is lost for the next 3 or 4 years, especially in the brutal Big East. So I say let the recruits go. It will save the basketball program’s reputation and that’s about the only good that will come from it. A lot rides on reputation; it directly leads to effectiveness and credibility, on and off the court. Need proof? Ask the Knicks’ James Dolan.